Celebrity Justice
Lawsuit Says "Judge Judy" Sends Blacks Packin'

An ex-producer for "Judge Judy" is claiming that he was canned for complaining that black litigants were being 86'd from the show.
Judge Judy
The lawsuit, filed in L.A. County Superior Court by former Senior Producer Jonathan Sebastien, alleges that Randy Douthit -- a supervisor -- told staffers, "We're not doing any more black shows," and "I don't want to hear black people arguing."

Sebastien claims when he complained about the alleged whitewashing, he says Douthit commanded his fellow producers to book "white upscale, pretty people" for Judge Judy, and to send black litigants to the "Judge Joe Brown" show. Brown's show is produced by the same company as "Judy."

Sebastien claims after he objected to the policy, his boss "berated and mocked him," and fired him on March 30. He is seeking unspecified damages from the show and CBS Paramount.

Judge Judy Sheindlin herself isn't named as a defendant. A rep for CBS Paramount tells TMZ, "CBS Paramount does not comment on pending litigation." A staffer from "Judge Judy" -- who did not want to be identified -- says the suit has "no merit" and that the claims are being being made by "a disgruntled former employee who was fired for cause."

Tags: Judge Judy, JudgeJudy

Reader Comments

(Page 4 of 6) Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

46. Personally I stopped watching the show a while back. I'm tired seeing blacks all over everything, but whites get crap when they want to see or work with whites. What's the big deal? Blacks can be proud to be black, have their own magazines, shows... so why can't it be the same for whites? Let's face it, blacks and whites ARE different so why should we be forced to merge everything together? I mean if that's the way the shows want it, cool... but don't make people do things they don't want to do.

Posted at 4:51PM on Dec 31st 2007 by Mary

47. Maury Povich has done more harm to Black people, especially since his show is shown all over the world, than any single human being alive today.

Why does he get away with it? Why don't we hear from Jesse and Al about this disgraceful show? Povich has gotten filthy rich off of displaying the worst, most degrading side of black human beings. I hope he rots in hell.

Posted at 5:31PM on Dec 31st 2007 by amazed at all this

48. ey, "amazed at all this"
don't blame Maury, those guests go on that show willingly,not forced.
and if it weren't for Maury paying for those paternity tests,those women still wouldn't know who the father of their kids are.

Posted at 6:25PM on Dec 31st 2007 by Kaili

49. Isn't Judge Judy black?

Posted at 6:41PM on Dec 31st 2007 by SuperStarSteve

50. # 45 amazing

I do agree with you to a certain extent but I also think that the black people don't need Maury Povich to make fools of them selves.. His show has turned into the black people who's your baby daddy show and I'm pretty sure all of the people in the audience are not getting paid or the one's on sttage, they make fools of themselves for free!!!

Posted at 6:47PM on Dec 31st 2007 by Potholder

51. I can't stand this woman.... every time I see her snooty face on TV... I have to change the channel immediately. I can't stand the show... I can't believe that these judge shows are so popular since there are so many on TV lately. Judge Judy is the worst... what a b*tch this woman is... cold hearted old b*tch... no wonder why her husband cheated on her years ago!! haha

Posted at 6:53PM on Dec 31st 2007 by EEK727

52. THERE YOU GO BLAMING JUDGE JUDY, AND BELEIVING THE STORY FROM A DISGRUNTED EMPLOYEE. ALWAYS PLAYING THE RACE CARD. SHE'S NOT EVEN INVOLVED WITH THIS, IT'S THE PRODUCERS. THERE ARE MOSTLY BLACKS ON ALL THESE SHOWS, SO WHAT'S THE PROBLEM???

Posted at 8:10PM on Dec 31st 2007 by JOANIE

53. Hey Franklin! R u the one who created this lawsuit? E-mail me! Wow @ at all the erroneous, slanderous, racist, idiotic, off the point of the article comments on this page, I don't even know where to begin. Well, the latest comment made by EEK727 falls under the category of libel. Jerry Sheindlin never cheated on Judge Judy. That wasn't the reason for their divorce before they got back together again. And I certainly don't know how we got into Maury Povich. I guess it had to do with some of these white whiners on this page turning thesubject (which really hasn't got anything to do with racism) into a racial matter, while ironically still making comments like "Don't bring up the race card" as if a black person is, when this is actually a white man who is accusing the show of racism against blacks.

GROUP OF IDIOTS 1. ON THIS PAGE (RACIST WHITE WHINERS) Ok, let me see if I can explain this to some of these racist white whiners so they understand it. This has to do with a guy who says he was fired for an outrageous reason. Whether you believe what Randy Douhthit may have said was or wasn't racist, it shouldn't have been a reason to fire him is what this case is about. The show says that is completely false. There aren't even any black people involved in this. It has to do with white people not getting along. How white people were able to make all these offensive comments about black people and start bringing up Maury Povich is beyond me.

GROUP OF IDIOTS 2. ON THIS PAGE (PEOPEL ACTING AS IF JUDY SHEINDLIN IS GETTING SUED) It seems like a big group of people didn't even bother to read the article. A number of people have made comments as if Judy Sheindlin herself is getting sued. Judge Judy is really not being sued and no money will come out of her pocket if the show loses the case. So making comments like "Judge Judy is racist" and some other comments I see on this page are idiotic.

ONE IDIOT One idiot on this page really got under my skin when he said, well judge judy is the best court show so there doing something right in not putting more of them on or something to this effect. By making this statement, you really insult the show and make it seem like the color of the litigant's skin in the majority of the show's cases is a big part of the show's success. You're a dumb a ss.

I, ladies and gentlemen, am surrounded by morons! Thank you and peace out! (NOTE: GOOGLE KNOL IS COMING TO TAKE OUT CRAPPY WIKIPEDIA. WIKIPEDIA (

Posted at 8:17PM on Dec 31st 2007 by MenThatLikeMenROCK

54. Dear men that like men,

Do you have a thing for Maury Povich?? It sure sounds like you do, all I said was his show is forum for all the black people to go to, And how can you say the lawsuit has nothing to do with race? Did you bother to read it??

Posted at 8:34PM on Dec 31st 2007 by Potholder

55. THIS STORY HASN'T EVEN BEEN PROVE TO BE THE TRUTH , SO WHY ALL THE HOSTILITY? AS SONN AS SOMEONE FILE A LAWSSUIT, AND ACCUSES ANYONE OF RACISM, YOU BELEIVE THEM, NOT FOR ANYTHING, BUT BLACKS USE THIS ALL THE TIME.I CAN'T BELEIVE THE STORY TILL IT'S PROVEN

Posted at 8:53PM on Dec 31st 2007 by JOANIE

56. Who's the idiot that thinks all white people are pretty??? Ignorance is rampant in America.

Posted at 8:29AM on Jan 1st 2008 by Jc

57. In all honesty, white folks are considered the most corrupt race what with all their antics from back in 2007. People like Lindsay Lohan, Britney Spears, Paris Hilton, Chris Benoit, Baywatch dude whatever his name is, Nick Hogan, Alec Baldwin (everything from drugs, rehab, drunk driving, hair cutting and balding to mistreatement of children, KILLING THEIR FAMILIES, partying parents who don't take care of their children, etc. Let's face it! White folks are out of control hypocrites that like to make it seem like black people are evil as they have done on this page. The worst things that happened this years in the entertainment world were pretty much all WHITE PEOPLE killing their families (Chris Benoit), yet they bring up friggin Maury! What a joke of a race

Posted at 9:31AM on Jan 1st 2008 by Arnold

58. Potholder, do u have a thing for pot? It sure sounds like you do. All I said was that your statement about Maury being a forum for all black people to go to was irrelevant. Was anyone fired from Maury for being against that? A question like that would be relevant. That's how the lawsuit has nothing to do with race. White people are so stupid

Posted at 9:52AM on Jan 1st 2008 by MenThatLikeMenROCK

59. No I don't have a thing for pot or for Maury Povich, I think your trying to justify his show because YOUR black and you can't stand the fact that everyy person on his show make morons of themselves everyday.

Posted at 10:28AM on Jan 1st 2008 by Potholder

60. you make fun of our race,how about the black
men who love White women.
make fun of us all you want,you blacks love us white girls.
and as far as white people killing everybody goes,please whatever.
these white people in the media you see,are all Celebrities,duh.
of course they are in the media.yeah, and i never see a story about a black person killing anyone.
i watch court tv a lot,and lots of these stories are black killers,gimme a break,only white people kill,
your an idiot.

Posted at 11:26AM on Jan 1st 2008 by cassy

Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments