Who'd You Rather?

61. SIMON of course. Taylor Hicks is NOT only 31 years old. I heard that he took away 8 years from his age to qualify for AI, so he should have his title stripped away. Oh never mind, it's already been stripped away by every other contestant.

Posted at 10:38AM on Oct 7th 2007 by Richiella

62. I just want to know why Taylor, in his very early 30's, looks the same age as, if not slightly older, than Simon! Since there's no neither button, I'd say Simon. He's apparently aging better!

Posted at 12:06PM on Oct 7th 2007 by Vanessa

63. Taylor - in a heartbeat.

Posted at 6:57PM on Oct 8th 2007 by hicksfan7

64. Taylor Hicks is definately the sexiest man I have seen in years. Taylor all the way.

Posted at 10:01AM on Oct 8th 2007 by whopbutt

65. Taylor all the way....Simon is hairy and has no lips. Taylor has a ton of sex appeal and a voice that makes me melt. He is one of the sexiest men I have ever seen.....totally tops any celebrity who you may photogragh.

Posted at 5:30PM on Oct 9th 2007 by Bernie2269

66. I pick Taylor (for sure).................he is a cutie!!!! Simon is also cute, but I would always feel like he was "judging me!"

I love Taylor Hicks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 4:16PM on Oct 8th 2007 by angie

67. TAYLOR, TAYLOR, TAYLOR!!! - THERE AIN'T NO OTHER MAN LIKE HIM!!!
HE HAS LOST OVER 25 POUNDS, AND HE LOOK SO MUCH YOUNGER WHEN YOU SEE HIM IN PERSON, BECAUSE HE IS YOUNG. THOSE EYES AND THAT SMILE ARE GORGEOUS! A REAL NATURAL TALENT! WHAT HE DOES WITH A HARMONICA, WHOA BABY! HE KNOCKS YOUR SOCKS OFF! I HAVE MET TAYLOR, AND HE HAS THAT REAL SEXY SOUTHERN STYLE! HE JUST MELTS ME!
SIMON IS JUST A RICH JERK WHO THINKS HE IS ALL THAT AND A BAG OF CHIPS!
TAYLOR BEAT HIM AT HIS OWN GAME!

Posted at 2:49AM on Oct 12th 2007 by BabyDoll

68. yeahh..NIETHER! I agree w/ everyone else...needs to be a "neither" option!

Posted at 6:23PM on Oct 17th 2007 by NIKS

69. Simon Cowell is a jerk and gives nothing back to America or the American people who have helped him aquire $250 million dollar fortune plus since AI started. He spends 1 million on cars .. America has made him very rich. He is self centered opinionated moron who is trying to compensate for a small .... He could try and learn go give back to America which as made him very rich.....like some of the other Celebs such as Bono, Celine Dion, Oprah, Paul McCartney, Richard Branson for the victims of Katrina. I guess his conistant in his personal life as he is on AI....Once a jerk, always a jerk.. send him home and deport him America will be better for it...tight fisted moron

Posted at 4:37PM on Nov 13th 2007 by send_him_home_across_the_pond

70. Simon Cowell is a jerk and gives nothing back to America or the American people who have helped him aquire $250 million dollar fortune plus since AI started. He spends 1 million on cars .. America has made him very rich. He is self centered opinionated moron who is trying to compensate for a small .... He could try and learn go give back to America which as made him very rich.....like some of the other Celebs such as Bono, Celine Dion, Oprah, Paul McCartney, Richard Branson for the victims of Katrina. I guess his conistant in his personal life as he is on AI....Once a jerk, always a jerk.. send him home and deport him America will be better for it...tight fisted moron

Posted at 4:41PM on Nov 13th 2007 by send_him_home_across_the_pond

71. I guess it pays to be a prick and insult people.. u can spend 2.5 millon on cars

I think it's all f*** up myself, our troops are dying and noone gives a crap,so this jerk can live the high life in Hollywood. He has made millions from America and doesn't give anything back .............we don't need him over here...go back to the UK PLEASE and take the Spice girls and Beckham with you.... limey parasites

Posted at 1:25PM on Nov 14th 2007 by sendthemhome