Who'd You Rather?

16. Simon..... yeah, baby!

Posted at 2:01AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Suzyh

17. 31 --- yeah, sure.

i'd rather eat a dirt sandwich than do either one of these jackasses.

Posted at 2:19AM on Oct 6th 2007 by pukey

18. Simon all the way! I love men with british accents.

Posted at 2:26AM on Oct 6th 2007 by lolabean

19. Even if I were a woman, I think I'd throw up in my mouth about these guys.

Posted at 2:54AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Do You Want Cheese On That?

20. I know he had to lie to get on the show and all, but he can tell the truth now. That guy hasn't seen 31 for the better part of a decade.

Posted at 3:56AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Izzy

21. UGH, why would you not put a "neither" option? I'll have night terrors at the mere thought!

Posted at 4:09AM on Oct 6th 2007 by FreixenetQueen

22. simon because he has way more money than the other dude.

Posted at 5:03AM on Oct 6th 2007 by the truth

23. What an unappealing selection. I'd be flying out of the country in a dark wig, Groucho nose and glasses if I "had" to do either one of these....yick

Posted at 11:49AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Aurora

24. Simon is way to full of himself for me, I see darkness in his eyes.

Taylor has light in his eyes. Taylor all the way.

Posted at 6:49AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Twinkle Twinkle

25. Simon hands down! He's hot, and has the aura of a nasty boy.

I like!

Posted at 7:45AM on Oct 6th 2007 by trinity

26. Ummm....neither!

Posted at 8:57AM on Oct 6th 2007 by www.sugar-shoes.co.uk

27. NEITHER !!!

Posted at 9:11AM on Oct 6th 2007 by robert

28. I'd rather not.

I'm 40. Taylor Hicks has more wrinkles than me. Maybe someday he'll write a book and reveal that he forged his birth certificate to get on 'Idol.'

Posted at 9:21AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Give Me a Break

29. neither!

Posted at 5:24PM on Oct 7th 2007 by Marisa

30. Hmmmmm I guess Taylor..He looks more like Clooney than Simon does.

Posted at 9:46AM on Oct 6th 2007 by Babette Sands